Sunday, June 26, 2005

An open letter to Karl Rove

Kristen Breitweiser lost her husband in the attack on the World Trade Center on 9/11. Here is her response to Karl Rove's outrageous claim that liberals only wanted to give the perpetrators "therapy and understanding". It's entitled, "Karl Rove's 'Understanding of 9/11'". Here's an excerpt:

It has always been America's policy that you only place soldiers' lives in harm's way when it is absolutely necessary and the absolute last resort. When you send troops into combat you support those troops by providing them with proper equipment and training. Why didn't you do that with the troops that you sent into Iraq? Why weren't their vehicles armored? Why didn't they have protective vests? Why weren't they properly trained about the rules of interrogation? And Karl, when our troops come home – be it tragically in body bags or with missing limbs – you should honor and acknowledge their service to their country. You shouldn't hide them by bringing them home in the dark of night. Most importantly, you should take care of them for the long haul by giving them substantial veteran's benefits and care. To me, that is being patriotic. To me, that is how you support our troops. To me, that is how you show that you know the value of a human life given for its country.

For the record Karl, does Iraq have any connection to the 9/11 attacks? Because, you and your friends with your collective “understanding of 9/11” seem to be contradicting yourselves about the Iraq-9/11 connection, too. First, we were told that we went to war with Iraq because it was linked to the 9/11 attacks. Then, your rationale was changed to "Iraq has WMD". Then you told us that we needed to invade Iraq because Saddam was a "bad man". And now it turns out that we are in Iraq to bring them "democracy."

Of course, the Downing Street memo clarifies many of these things, but for the record Karl: Iraq had nothing to do with 9/11; there were few terrorists in Iraq before our invasion, but now Iraq is a terrorist hot-bed. America had the sympathy and support of the whole world before Iraq. Now, thanks to your actions, we find ourselves hated and alienated by the rest of the world. Al Qaeda's recruitment took a nose-dive after the 9/11 attacks, but has now skyrocketed since your invasion of Iraq; and most importantly, nearly 2,000 U.S. soldiers have been killed because of your war in Iraq. These facts speak for themselves. (And, they speak very little about effectively winning any war on terror.)

Karl, you say you “understand” 9/11. Then why did you and your friends so vehemently oppose the creation of a 9/11 Independent Commission? Once the commission was established, why did you refuse to properly fund the Commission by allotting it only a $3 million budget? Why did you refuse to allow access to documents and witnesses for the 9/11 Commissioners? Why did we have to fight so hard for an extension when the Commissioners told us that they needed more time due to your footdragging and stonewalling? Why didn't you want to cooperate so that all Americans could “understand” what happened on 9/11?

Every word of this letter is good. I recommend that you read it all.

Speaking of hatred of the United States, did you know that anti-American setiment has turned so ugly that American students studying there are being overwhelmed by the harassment to the point that they can't take it and leave? Here's an article published in Australia about the problem entitled, "Students quit over anti-US slurs". This is simply tragic. I'm about to leave for Ireland and England later this week to visit old friends and I'm really concerned about my reception when I'm in public. I just hope I can pick up my old Irish accent quickly.

1 comment:

  1. Anonymous7:44 AM

    After reading this article in the Australian "The Sunday Times", even though I don't agree with any kind of harrassment, it seems to me that Americans might learn a long overdue lesson: Not everybody likes you or your government policies or your culture. Unfortunately of course, it is shown to people you least deserve it and are the least responsible for the mess the world is in today.


New policy: Anonymous posts must be signed or they will be deleted. Pick a name, any name (it could be Paperclip or Doorknob), but identify yourself in some way. Thank you.